2017年3月托福寫作真題回憶及范文賞析(一)

　　閱讀：出土了一種用陶土做的disk ，一面有花紋，一面沒花紋。沒花紋那面周圍有一圈凸起剛好形成了一個(gè)淺淺的碗。disk 下面還有短短的手柄。這種disk 有三種可能的用法。

　　1、用來做飯， disk 無花紋面的碗剛好可以盛放食物，而手柄方便烹飪的時(shí)候移動(dòng)disk 。

　　2、用來當(dāng)鼓，往disk 上蒙上獸皮，就可以形成一個(gè)腔體。人們可以一手持手柄，一手擊鼓。

　　3、用作鏡子。往無花紋面里到些液體，就可以當(dāng)鏡子用了。而且，這種用法很像古希臘的手持鏡子。

　　聽力：上用法都不可信不可能用于烹飪的。想一想我們家里用的pans and pots ，使用之后會blackend or

　　discolored ，因?yàn)殚L時(shí)間接觸高溫，炊具勢必會發(fā)黑。但是出土的200 件disk 中沒有一個(gè)出現(xiàn)了這種情況。

　　做鼓使用也不可能發(fā)出好聽的聲音。這中disk 使用陶土制作，即使蒙上獸皮敲擊的聲音也遠(yuǎn)不如用獸皮和木頭制作的鼓好聽。此外，陶土制作的鼓非常沉，使用不便。

　　無法當(dāng)作鏡子。倒入液體后， disk 就必須被水平放置，這樣人們可以彎腰照鏡子。但是被水平放置后，有花紋的那一面就看不見了。古希臘的鏡子是手持的，垂直拿在手里，這樣可以隨時(shí)看見鏡子的花紋。

　　Sample Answer:

　　About the function of disks, the reading mentions three hypotheses, which are refuted by the listening one by one with the following arguments.

　　The first possible function of disks, raised by the reading, is for cooking. The listening, however, is opposite to this point by further explaining that after being heated for a long time, cookers must be blackened or discolored, just like pans and pots at our home. But the fact is that among the 200 unearthed disks, none of them is blackened or discolored.

　　Regarding to the drum theory, the listening still disagrees with it. For one thing, it could not produce sound that is pleasing to ears for this kind of disk is made of clay, which, even though covered with hides, could not produce sound that is better than that produced by drums made of hides and wood. For another, drums made of clay are too heavy, making it much inconvenient to use. The listening, therefore, casts doubt on what the reading indicates.

　　Finally, the reading states that disks could serve as mirrors. This opinion is in sharp contrast with the belief in the listening that it is unlikely that disks are used as mirrors. After pouring liquid, disks must be laid horizontally. And people could look in the mirror by bending down. But the problem is that with the mirror being horizontal, the side which is decorated could not be seen. But the Greek mirrors are held by hands so that the decorative pattern is visible. ( 251 words )

　　獨(dú)立

　　Nowadays, many movies or films are based on books. Some people prefer to read the original book before they watch the movie, other prefer to watch the movie before reading the book. Which one do you prefer?

　　Sample Answer:

　　The movie industry has witnessed an unprecedented boom during recent years with endless movies coming into view. Among the ample supply of movies, many are based on original books, which provides the general public two choices about the order of reading books and watching movies. Some prefer to watch the movie followed by reading the book. According to my preference, I would like to read the original book first.

　　The primary reason for my stance is that by reading the original book, I am allowed to let my imagination run wild. To illustrate, the original book shows us the detailed plots without displaying the specific characters on screen or through pictures. Therefore, we are free to imagine without the constraints of movies. Conversely, characters in the movies have already been chosen and designed including their facial expressions, body language and even dressing styles, which leaves us few chances to make full use of our imagination and curiosity to think logically. It is no wonder that giving priority to the original books provides us with more fun, for it is imagination that contributes to happiness.

　　Another factor tempts me to make such a choice is that I will have a deeper understanding of what is hidden behind the movie after reading the book. As we all know, movies are always adapted, some details of which are unavoidably deleted owing to the limitation of time. Accordingly, it is highly possible that some plots and lines are too abstract to understand. The original book, on the other hand, clearly explains the background, hence not giving rise to confuse. I always have a glimpse of the original books before reading the adapted movies, with A Dream of Red Mansions a clear case in point. The book A Dream of Red Mansions mainly describes a touching love story between Jia Baoyu and his cousin Lin Daiyu, which begins and ends in a luxurious mansion. Hardly could I understand why Lin Daiyu always quarreled with Jia Baoyu in the movie if I did not take time to read the book.

　　Frankly speaking, movies are short enough for us to make a quick decision about whether it is to our taste and whether it is worth reading the original book. But as mentioned above, movies are adapted more often than not, which cannot serve as the determining factor of whether the original book is a good one.

　　To sum up, reading the book before watching the movie is definitely a more preferable choice, for it will beget imagination and curiosity as well as a deeper comprehension.

　　(429 words )